One of the most popular types of makeup to wear on a regular basis is eyeliner. Eyeliner is a basic, easy to use, and popular choice for helping to accentuate the eyes and to help complete your eye makeup look! It comes in so many different colors and shades to play around with – brown, black, gold, silver, blue, green, purple, and the list just keeps going.
You can find pretty much any color you want these days!
But have you ever thought about what ingredients might be lurking in your eyeliner? Think about it, eyeliner is put on super close to your eyes. If you are using a liquid eyeliner, you may even wind up having some bleed into your eye by accident. Now, if that eyeliner is filled with chemicals and toxic ingredients, you are subjecting your very delicate, sensitive, and important eyes to a lot of harsh stuff.
Since your skin can absorb quite a bit of the stuff we put on, many of those chemical ingredients in your eyeliner are going to absorb right through the eyelids and underpart of the eye.
Your eyes are one of your most important body parts, and it is absolutely necessary to keep them healthy and safe. Using chemical-laden eyeliners are putting your eyes and health at risk every time you apply it. It is simply not worth the risk, especially when there are some truly amazing natural and organic eyeliners available on the market.
Plus, your eyeliners are the thinnest skin you have on your body, which means there is an even greater chance of having the chemicals from conventional eyeliner seep into your skin and eyes quickly – yikes!
With that being said, the best way to avoid all of these dangers and issues is to go with natural and organic options you can feel safe using daily. Many people worry that a natural option is going to smudge or not perform as well as popular conventional brands, but that is simply not true.
We will also take a peek at some ingredients you should avoid in eyeliners the most and give you a fun DIY version for eyeliner you can try to make at home. We know you have some time on your hands during this time!
The 10 Best Natural and Organic Eyeliners:
Below we explore 10 of the best natural and organic eyeliners that we know you’re absolutely going to love.
This all-day wear liquid eyeliner works incredibly well and stays in place just the way you would want it to. It is deeply pigmented and even water-resistant, which is awesome for such a natural and pure eyeliner. It will not smudge, it won’t drip, and you’ll never have to worry about it going anywhere.
Instead of synthetic colors, they dye their eyeliner with superfine black tea powder and fresh cocoa. It gives the eyeliner the deepest and richest color possible – you will be blown away. As far as the brush for the eyeliner goes, it has a super point and fine tip, so you get the most precise application possible for even the most complicated of looks.
This eyeliner is also great if you have sensitive skin. It has soothing and moisturizing aloe in it to keep your skin feeling moist and comfortable and giving you peace of mind that it will not crack and flake off during the day.
Zuzu is a natural makeup brand that so many people love and trust. They have great high-quality products with high performance and right pigmentation. This eyeliner is liquid and comes in the form of a calligraphy pen for easy and smooth application every time.
In this eyeliner, you will never find any gluten, parabens, coal tar, animal products, or any other harsh and highly toxic chemicals. Instead, you will get an eyeliner with wholesome ingredients like jojoba oil, aloe, and pigments from natural minerals. They are known for using many herbs, botanicals, and vitamins in their products that are soothing and refreshing for your skin.
Honeybee Gardens is one of the cleanest beauty and skincare brands on the market. This is a traditional eyeliner pencil and it comes in a couple of different shades, from blacks to browns and a few fun natural colors. They have created a smooth formula in a pencil that will not pull or drag your skin and it will go on with easy application in one swipe across the lash line.
Their eyeliner is made in Germany and is Gluten-Free, Vegan, Paraben Free, and PETA Certified Cruelty Free. You will also never find any phthalates, SLS, fragrances from chemicals, talc, gluten, or petroleum-based ingredients.
Avril is a certified organic eyeliner that never contains any parabens, phenoxyethanol, or potassium sorbate. This is also never tested on animals and it is made in France where they have stricter policies when it comes to what they can put into makeup products. This is a long-lasting eyeliner pencil to goes is easily and smoothly.
You will be able to wear it all day and night without the dear it is ever going to smudge or drip from your eyes. You can choose from a few different shades of colors like blue, black, brown, grey, greens, metallics, white, rose gold, and a few more, so you will never run out of any fun and exciting color options to try!
This is another certified organic long-lasting eyeliner that you are definitely going to fall in love with. It is a highly pigmented extra-black eyeliner that is as bold and dark as you could want. It is made with wholesome and natural ingredients like coconut oil, jojoba oil, avocado, baobab oil, and the powerful antioxidant vitamin E. the eyeliner is also vegan, cruelty-free, and made in Italy.
The consistency of this eyeliner is creamy and smooth, so it goes on your eyelash lines flawlessly. It is completely smudged proof and has incomparable wear for nearly 8 hours! Plus, it will also never ever get cakey.
Their special formula is free from mineral oil, sulfates SLS and SLES, parabens, formaldehyde, formaldehyde-releasing agents, phthalates, retinyl palmitate, oxybenzone, coal tar, hydroquinone, triclosan, and triclocarban.
This soft matte black eyeliner comes in pencil form, but it is so easy to use and applies to your lash lines with total ease. Since the pencil is so soft, it glides across your eyes super easy and there is no pulling or tugging of the skin, which often leads to a messy and uneven application. For this to happen, they use natural and high-quality ingredients like jojoba oil, shea butter, vitamin E, sunflower oil, and vitamin C to help the liner glide on. These ingredients also provide you with long-lasting color that is not going to fade throughout the day.
Another eyeliner pencil, this brand creates a pencil with rich pigmentation in a variety of colors to choose from depending on your mood. Their liner never contains and animal bi-products, synthetic preservatives, nano particles, gluten, parabens, fillers, dyes, or toxins. What they do include are healthy and wholesome ingredients like jojoba oil, castor seed oil, calendula wax, and mineral pigments to give their liners their colors. All of their mineral pigments are non-nano particles, so they don’t absorb into your bloodstream.
The texture of this eyeliner pencil is smooth, velvety, and easy to apply to the eyes so you can achieve any look and style you are going for. They include ingredients in their formula that are soothing for the skin around your eyes like chamomile, meadowfoam, and Vitamin E. Of course, they never use any gluten, parabens, talc, artificial colors, synthetic fragrances, SLS, phthalates. All of their products are cruelty-free as well. We know you are going to love this option since they use mineral-based pigments and never any synthetic dyes.
If you have never tried out a gel-cream eyeliner before you will want to give this natural and organic option a try ASAP. It is versatile because you can apply it as is, but can also smudge it or smoke it out for more dramatic looks. However, it is important to keep in mind that gel-cream liners such as this are extremely pigmented and are meant to give you a much bolder and more powerful look overall, even when used like just a regular eyeliner. As for their formula, it is 75% organic, vegan, non-toxic, gluten-free, cruelty-free, and made in the USA.
100% vegan and cruelty-free, Pacifica Beauty is a popular and trusted natural brand that so many people love, and this eyeliner is no exception. Its buttery and smooth application is made possible with healthy and wholesome ingredients like jojoba oil, shea butter, vitamin E, and vitamin C. There are no chemicals or toxic ingredients in their eyeliner formulas, so you can feel safe and comfortable using a product that is applied so close to your eye.
Ingredients to Avoid in Conventional Eyeliner
- Color additives. Color additives come from unnatural and synthetic sources and can be dyes, pigments, or other chemical substances that produce color in your eyeliner. One of the biggest issues with all types of synthetic color is they are oftentimes carcinogenic. This means they are known to cause cancer in humans. When looking at the ingredient list, the synthetic colors will be labeled as FD&C or D&C along with a number. For instance, look out for ingredients that look like this: FD&C Red No. 6.
- Polysorbate 20. This is another common ingredient found in makeup and eyeliner as well. It is known to cause allergic reactions and skin irritation in some people. Polysorbate is a particular problem if this chemical is contaminated by other certain chemicals. The combination of certain chemicals with polysorbate can cause extreme and dangerous health issues, such as birth defects.
- Fragrance. If there is going to be one ingredient you avoid in makeup and all other products for the rest of your life, let it be fragrance. It is sometimes also referred to as parfum on the ingredient list. This is why hundreds, if not thousands, of chemicals, can lurk in your eyeliner. Companies and the FDA do not require any ingredients in fragrance to be listed or disclosed anywhere. You will never have any idea what those extra added chemicals in fragrance are.
- Propylene glycol. This chemical is derived from petroleum. Therefore, there are some concerns that this ingredient is a possible human carcinogen. Some more research needs to be done on this ingredient to truly see what the effects of putting it on your body maybe, but if you want to stay safe for sure, try to avoid this chemical when you can.
How to Make a DIY Eyeliner
If you don’t want to spend the money on a natural and organic eyeliner, since they can be a bit pricier than the cheaper drugstore versions, or if you’re stuck at home and super bored, you can try your hand at making this easy DIY eyeliner!
It is super simple and doesn’t require a massive amount of ingredients. You may need to buy some of the items online and have them shipped to your house.
- Activated charcoal
- Distilled or filtered water
- Small jar with lid
- Mix 1 tablespoon of activated charcoal with a few drops of water at a time. It works well to use an eyedropper. You are looking to have a paste texture.
- Mix well until there are no lumps left in the mixture. It should look smooth.
- Store in a cool and dry place.
- When you are ready to apply the eyeliner, take a small eyeliner brush and press into your eyelash lines. Wipe any excess eyeliner away.
- It helps if you use a face primer or foundation under the eyeliner to keep it in place, so there is less of a chance for it to smudge a lot.
Frequently Asked Questions
Why Use Organic Eyeliners?
Organic eyeliners are made from natural ingredients and are known to be safe for use. They come in a variety of colors that can create different looks. These eyeliners are also easy to apply and remove with little effort.
In the past, people used to use conventional eyeliners that were made from chemicals and had a high risk of causing irritation, allergic reactions, and even eye infections. With the advent of organic eyeliners, this risk has been greatly reduced since they don’t contain harmful chemicals like conventional ones do.
How Do Organic Eyeliners Work?
Organic eyeliners are applied to the waterline and create a gradient eye look. The organic ingredients in the formula make the eyeliner more sustainable, safe for use around any eyeshadow, and easier and less intimidating to apply than traditional eyeliners.
Do Organic Eyeliners Work?
Yes organic eyeliners work. Organic eyeliners work best on eyes that have good moisture. They can also be used to highlight the eyebrows and create a dramatic effect without a lot of color.
Are Organic Eyeliners Safe?
Yes, most organic eyeliners are safe. Organic eyeliners are a great way to get a natural look, but when it comes to health, you may be wondering if they’re safe. There have been many claims that organic eyeliners contain toxic ingredients or carcinogens. However, organic eyeliner brands claim that their products are made with certified organic ingredients and natural preservatives.
Where to Buy Organic Eyeliners?
There are many places to buy organic eyeliners that you can find online. You can search for these products in local retailers or even on the manufacturer’s website.
As you can see, there are plenty of reasons why you should truly consider switching from a chemical-laden conventional eyeliner to healthy, organic, and natural eyeliner. Not only is it so much safer for your eyes, skin, and body as a whole, you are also getting higher quality formulas that are made with significantly better ingredients.
Therefore, while you may have to spend a tad more on a natural and organic option, you are doing a whole lot of good for your body and for the planet as well. The fewer chemicals we use in our everyday lives mean the fewer chemicals that are winding up polluting our earth.
In the end, making the switch to a natural option has never been easier since we have provided you with the top 10 best natural and organic eyeliners on the market! Need some gorgeous and organic eyeshadow to go along with your eyeliner? Check out these amazing options.
This article was last updated on May 15, 2023 .